Assessing Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms in Chinese Vitiligo Patients

Introduction

Vitiligo is a common depigmentation skin disease due to the loss of melanocytes.¹ The clinical manifestations are depigmentation spots of different sizes in skin and mucosa, which can be involved in any part of the body and hair. The incidence of vitiligo in the whole world is about 0.5–1% and the incidence varies from race to region and population.^2,3 Skin lesions range from very limited to generalized. It also is a disfigurement disease. In addition to affecting individual mental and physical health, it also increases the economic burden of patients and their families, and affects the quality of life of patients.⁴

The etiology and pathogenesis of vitiligo are very complex. It is generally believed that individuals with genetic tendency show abnormalities in autoimmunity, oxidative stress, endocrine metabolism, neuropsychiatric and other aspects under the stimulation of a variety of inflammatory factors, resulting in melanin synthesis disorder or melanocyte destruction, and finally lead to depigmentation.¹ Vitiligo is often misunderstood as a cosmetic disease.⁵ A large number of clinical practices have shown that patients with vitiligo often have stress events such as overwork, tension, anxiety and mental trauma before the onset of vitiligo.^6,7 Psychosocial conditions affect the immune system and play a role in the disease process. More and more attention has been paid to the role of psychosocial factors in the occurrence and development of psychosomatic diseases. Research on the psychosocial factors in vitiligo has been reported.^7–9 Therefore, vitiligo is a skin psychological disease that will not directly lead to physical damage but will lead to serious psychological problems in daily life.¹⁰

In general, clarifying the psychological and behavioral characteristics of patients with vitiligo, understanding their potential psychological and behavioral symptoms (such as anxiety, depression and social disorder), can help optimize the management of vitiligo, improve the treatment effect, improve the quality of life and promote their physical and mental health development.¹¹

However, there are few researches on psychological symptoms in patients with vitiligo in China. This study aim to investigate the psychological and behavioral status in patients with vitiligo in China through psychological and behavioral related questionnaires, analyze the influencing factors of psychological and behavioral problems, and provide theoretical basis for comprehensive treatment and clinical intervention of vitiligo.

Methods

Ethics

The study and protocols were approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Xi’an Jiaotong University, and performed according to guidelines governing ethics care in China. This study was performed in accordance with the rules laid down in the Declaration of Helsinki. Informed consent has been obtained from all patients for study participation, data collection and publication.

Participants

The convenient sampling method was used to select adult patients with vitiligo who came to the dermatology clinic of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Xi’an Jiaotong University from March 2019 to November 2019 as the research object. The inclusion criteria were: 1. All patients were over 18 years old. 2. The diagnosis of vitiligo was made by two dermatologists and wood lamp. 3. All patients had no previous history of mental illness. 4. All patients had no cognitive orientation disorder, had primary school education or above, and could understand the meaning of the questionnaires. 5. All patients voluntarily participated, and expressed their willingness to cooperate to complete the questionnaires carefully. Exclusion criteria were: 1. Patients were under 18 years old. 2. Patients with other skin diseases or major physical or neurological diseases (tumors, heart problems, liver and kidney dysfunction, epilepsy, etc.) that may impair their quality of life or psycho-behavioral status.

Measures

The initial sample consisted of 120 participants, after eliminating the questionnaires invalidated by their incorrect completion, the final sample was 117 (97.5%) in this study. The researcher gave explanation and guidance when necessary. All questionnaires were filled in on site and completed by the patients themselves. All patients who met the inclusion criteria were evaluated by general information questionnaire, dermatology quality of life index (DLQI), symptom checklist 90 (SCL-90), social avoidance and distress scale (SADS) and medical coping style scale (MCMQ). All questionnaires were in Chinese and the validated forms were used.

DLQI is currently the most widely used dermatological life quality questionnaire. It includes 10 questions related to symptoms and feelings, daily activities, leisure, work and school, interpersonal relationship and treatment, to evaluate the impact of skin diseases on patients’ quality of life during the previous 1 week.¹² According to the total score of DLQI, the score is divided into 5 grades. 0~1 indicates almost no influence, 2~5 indicates small influence, 6~10 indicates moderate influence, 11~20 indicates very large influence, and 21~30 indicates extremely large influence.

The SCL-90 scale is used for self-assessment by people over the age of 16 and is one of the most well-known mental health testing scales in the world. It consists of 90 items, assessed from 10 factors of somatization, obsessive-compulsive, interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, hostility, phobia, paranoid ideation, psychoticism, sleeping and eating state. According to their self-perception of the psychological state, the subjects rate their symptoms using a scale ranging from 1 to 5 on a scale corresponding to “none”, “very light”, “moderate”, “heavy”, and “severe”. The higher the score, the worse the mental health of the subject.¹³

SADS was compiled by Waston et al in 1969, and the Chinese version was revised by Hong Ma et al, which has been proved to have good reliability and validity.¹⁴ The scale consists of 28 items, including two dimensions of social avoidance and social distress, with 14 questions for each dimension and the score range from 0 to 28 points. The higher the score, the more severe the degree of social avoidance and distress.

MCMQ was formed into a formal Chinese version of the questionnaire by Qianjin Jiang et al, combined with the original Chinese translation version and revised several times.¹⁵ Twenty items are assigned to three coping styles: facing (8 items), avoiding (7 items) and yielding (5 items). Using a four-point scoring method (1–4 points), the total score is 20 to 80 points, and the higher the subscale score, the more obvious the coping style.

Statistical Analyses

The collected data were entered into excel and checked by two investigators, and the data were statistically analyzed by SPSS 18.0 statistical software. The mean ± standard deviation was used to describe the measurement data. Single sample t-test, one way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and two independent sample t-test were used to compare the differences. Spearman two-variable correlation analysis was used to analyze the correlation. P < 0.05 was statistically significant.

Results

Basic Demographic Data

As shown in Table 1, a total of 117 patients completed the questionnaires, including 49 males (41.9%) and 68 females (58.1%). The ratio of men to women was 1:1.39. Most patients (67.5%) were younger than 40 years old and had no positive family history (76.9%). For severity of disease, 65.8% patients were mild. More than half of the patients (58.1%) were in progressive stage and 12.0% in rapid progress stage.

Table 1 Demographic Data of Patients with Vitiligo

 

DLQI Scores of Patients with Vitiligo

The DLQI scores of 117 patients with vitiligo in this survey ranged from 0 to 26 points, and the mean score was 7.56 ± 6.11. 15 of 117 patients (12.8%) had a score of 0–1, indicating that vitiligo had almost no impact on their quality of life, and 39 patients scored 2–5, up to 33.3%, 31 patients (26.5%) had a score of 6–10, meaning that vitiligo had a moderate impact on them. There were 25 (21.4%) patients with 11–20 points. 7 (6.0%) scored more than 20, which impacted of the quality of life greatly, see Figure 1.

Figure 1 The distribution of DLQI (dermatology quality of life index) scores of patients with vitiligo.

 

Mental Health Status and Univariate Analysis of Patients with Vitiligo

The mental health status of 117 patients with vitiligo was evaluated by SCL-90 questionnaire. As shown in Table 2, the mean score was 136.44 ± 39.19, which was significantly higher than the Chinese norm of SCL-90 (129.19 ± 40.25)¹³ (P < 0.05). Among the 10 factors, the scores of depression, anxiety, interpersonal sensitivity and phobia were significantly higher than the Chinese norms¹³ (all P < 0.05).

Table 2 Comparison Between SCL-90 Score in Patients with Vitiligo and Chinese Norms (mean±SD)

 

For Single factor analysis, as shown in Table 3, in terms of the total score of SCL-90 and the scores of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety and phobia, it was found that female patients were significantly higher than those of men (P < 0.05), the married group were lower than those in the unmarried group (P < 0.05), the patients in rapid progression stage were significantly higher than those in progressive and stable stage (P < 0.05), and patients with skin lesions on the exposed site also scored significantly higher compared with those without exposed lesions (P < 0.05). In addition, it was found that there were significant differences in interpersonal sensitivity and depression scores among patients with different diseases severity (both P < 0.05).

Table 3 Univariate Analysis of Patients with Vitiligo in the Score of Total SCL-90 and Interpersonal Sensitivity, Depression, Anxiety and Phobia (Mean ± SD)

 

Social Status and Univariate Analysis of Patients with Vitiligo

The scores of SADS in 117 patients with vitiligo in this survey ranged from 0 to 26, the mean score was 10.30 ± 6.38, and the mean score of social avoidance was 5.13 ± 3.38 and social distress was 5.17 ± 3.67. Compared with the Chinese norm,¹⁴ it was found that the differences were statistically significant (P < 0.05), see Table 4.

Table 4 Comparison Between SADS Score in Patients with Vitiligo and Chinese Norms (mean±SD)

 

For single factor analysis of social status of patients with vitiligo, the score of social avoidance in women was higher than that in men (5.69 ± 3.39 vs 4.35 ± 3.24, t = 2.156, P = 0.033). The total scores of SADS and social distress in the junior middle school group were significantly higher than those in the other three groups (all P < 0.05). For severity of disease, the total SADS and social avoidance scores in mild group were significantly lower than that of severe group (all P < 0.05). The total score of SADS, social avoidance and social distress score of patients in rapid progressive stage were significantly higher than those in the other two groups (P < 0.05), see Table 5.

Table 5 Univariate Analysis of Patients with Vitiligo in the Score of Total SADS, Social Avoidance and Social Distress (mean±SD)

 

Medical Coping Mode in Patients with Vitiligo

The score of face coping was lower than the Chinese norm,¹⁵ and the scores of yield coping and avoidance coping were higher than the Chinese norm (P < 0.05), see Table 6.

Table 6 Comparison Between MCMQ Score in Patients with Vitiligo and Chinese Norms (mean±SD)

 

Impact of Medical Coping Style on Patients’ Mental Health

As shown in Table 7, yield coping and avoidance coping were positively correlated with the scores of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety and phobia (all P < 0.05). Face coping was negatively correlated with social avoidance and distress (P < 0.05), and yield coping and avoidance coping were positively correlated with social avoidance and distress (all P < 0.05), see Table 8.

Table 7 Impact of Medical Coping on Patients’ Mental Health

Table 8 Impact of Medical Coping on Patients’ Social Status

 

Discussion

Vitiligo is a common acquired depigmentation skin and mucous membrane disease, which can involve hair follicles. This disease is easy to diagnose, but difficult to treat. Repeated recurrence, and the change of appearance will damage the physical and mental health of patients to varying degrees.

Vitiligo will not bring serious health problems to patients, but lead to serious cosmetic problems. Many studies have shown that vitiligo lesions have a certain impact on the quality of life of patients.^16,17 Consistent with the DLQI score in the world,¹⁷ the overall average score was 8.2, which was in the third level. The DLQI score of the 117 patients investigated in our study was (7.56 ± 6.11), in the third-level effect, indicating that vitiligo had a moderate impact on the quality of life of patients. DLQI scores are concentrated in 2–20 points, which is in the second to fourth level of influence. It is worth noting that 32 (27.4%) patients had DLQI scores higher than 10 in our research, indicating that the disease had a great impact on their quality of life. The change of appearance will affect the personality characteristics and social relations of patients to a certain extent. Studies have shown that the quality of life of patients with vitiligo is significantly related to their psychological distress and mental health.¹⁸ Importantly, the quality of life of vitiligo may be largely affected by psychosocial comorbidity.¹⁹

Skin plays an essential role in our interaction with the world, and skin color is important in perceiving someone’s health.²⁰ The results of our study showed that the total score of SCL-90 was 136.44, which is significantly higher than the Chinese norm. The mental health problems of patients with vitiligo in China are mainly manifested as interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, and phobic anxiety. In this study, the total scores and all dimensions of SADS in vitiligo patients were significantly higher than the Chinese norms, indicating that compared with the general population, vitiligo patients had obvious social distress and social avoidance.

Many studies have shown that vitiligo has a greater impact on women’s mental health, and women are more prone to have mental symptoms and social disorders. Vitiligo sufferers experience limited participation in social interactions, job opportunities, religious activities, making friends, etc., showing significant social anxiety and avoidance.²¹ Compared with men, women experienced severe social distress, anxiety, and avoidance. In the study of Sawant,²² it was found that the degree of helplessness, depression and anxiety, social anxiety/avoidance and participation restriction of women were significantly higher than that of men. In our study, the scores of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, phobia and social avoidance in women were significantly higher than men. Men and women have different psychosocial reactions to vitiligo. Women may pay more attention to their self-image, have more sensitive thoughts, and are more likely to feel embarrassed and ashamed of the reactions of people around them. Adverse emotional reactions make them become more helpless and negative when face to diseases. They take the initiative to avoid some social activities and avoid going out to contact with people. Moreover, men and women have different understanding and value to the relationship between marriage and love. Female patients are more worried about the impact of vitiligo on their mate selection and marital status, and the social acceptance of women suffering from vitiligo is low, which makes them more vulnerable.

Studies have shown that vitiligo has a negative impact on patients’ life and marital status. Patients with vitiligo feel troubled and ashamed when they start sexual relations and emotional experience.¹⁰ Our study showed that unmarried patients have more negative symptoms of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety and phobia than married patients. The score of social avoidance and distress were slightly higher than that of married people, but the difference is not significant, indicating that both unmarried people and married people all suffer from social distress and avoidance. Education level is an important demographic characteristic of an individual, which affects person’s cognitive behavior to a great extent. A study showed that the higher the level of education, the more the patients can rationally understand the disease and reduce the burden caused by the disease.²³ Consistent with the results of our study, the scores of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, phobia, social avoidance and distress of patients with junior high school education are higher than those with senior high school, junior college, undergraduate, graduate and above education. With the increase of disease severity, the scores of vitiligo patients in interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, phobia, social avoidance and distress showed an upward trend. Patients with severe pigmented diseases have an increased frequency of mental illness.²⁴ The scores of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, phobia, social avoidance and distress in skin lesions with rapid progression were significantly higher than those in progressive and stable stage. The scores of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, phobia, social distress and avoidance of patients with skin lesions at the exposed site were higher than those without skin lesions at the exposed site, but only significant difference in the level of mental health, indicating that the mental health status of patients with the exposed lesions was worse than that of patients without lesions at the exposed site.²³

In this study, the face coping score of patients with vitiligo was significantly lower than the Chinese norm, and the yield and avoidance coping scores were significantly higher than the Chinese norms. And face coping was negatively correlated with patients’ social avoidance and distress, and yield and avoidance coping were positively correlated with patients’ interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, phobia, social avoidance and distress. Scholars believe that the psychological intervention treatment of vitiligo should start with the treatment education of patients. Through the education of disease and standardized treatment, we can improve patients’ cognitive level of disease, significantly reduce the anxiety and fear, and increase their belief in actively facing disease.¹¹

Participants with a good understanding of vitiligo were more likely to show a positive attitude toward vitiligo patients than those with insufficient knowledge of the disease.²⁵ In addition to psychotherapy and/or counseling for patients, general education on vitiligo for unaffected people may help to reduce the stigma associated with vitiligo and improve the psychosocial health of patients and their caregivers.

This study also has some limitations: 1. This study only conducted a sampling survey in one hospital. 2. The sample size is limited, resulting in a small number of cases collected in some age, diseases severity and stage. Multicenter and large sample research should be done in the future. 3. We not used VitiQoL tool to analyze the quality of life of patients with vitiligo.²⁶ 4. There is no research on the effect of psychotherapy in patients with vitiligo.

Conclusion

In China, vitiligo affects the quality of life of patients to varying degrees, resulting in a series of psychological and behavioral problems, including interpersonal sensitivity, depression, anxiety, phobia, social avoidance and distress, which are mainly affected by the patients’ social demographic situation (gender, marital status, educational level), disease-related situation (stage, severity, whether there are skin lesions at the exposed site) and coping style. At the same time of routine treatment, clinicians should also actively pay attention to and improve the mental health and behavior of patients with vitiligo.

Other Reads : Factors Affecting Quality Of Life In Patients With Vitiligo Part 1